Inspired by Paul Schaffer and the CBS Orchestra’s song choice last night, here’s how Alan W. Pollack concludes his notes on the Beatles’ “Tomorrow Never Knows”:
This track bears the ironic fate of being the first one recorded back in April 1966 for the new-album-in-progress, while in more ways than one, it was destined from early on to be last track of the album.
On a rather immediate level, I’ve always enjoyed the way that the preceding song, “Got To Get You Into My Life” being in G with an extended outro vamping on that chord, sets up “Tomorrow Never Knows”’s being in C as though the two songs together create a decisive V -» I ending for the album. But there are issues that run much deeper.
For one thing, having this one already in the can before the stylistic breadth and running order of “Revolver” had much yet crystallized gave them the strategically compositional advantage of knowing in advance the exact placement of the vanishing perspective point for the entire album. Consider how the sequencing of the entire album works toward this song.
For another thing, there is so much inherent in this track which forces it to be in the final position. I’m reminded, in this connection, of a wonderful essay embedded by Thomas Mann within his novel, “Dr. Faustus,” in which he explains why Beethoven intentionally cast his final piano sonata, Op. 111, in the unusual form of only two movements, the second of which is a slow movement in theme and variations. Commenting on the relationship of Op. 111 to the entirety of the piano sonata as a genre, Mann says that, “as a species, as traditional art-form; it itself was here at an end, brought to its end, it had fulfilled its destiny, reached its goal, beyond which there was no going, it canceled and resolved itself, it took leave …” While it is an exaggeration to say that the Rock Song genre was in any sense “finished off” by a single song like our “Tomorrow Never Knows”, it is worth pondering the extent to which a single track can be said to have raised the stakes, and taken the genre to some kind of crossroads from which it would be a challenge to all, the Beatles themselves not excepted, to figure out where to proceed next.
Granted, I doubt that I can muster any objective proof that the Beatles entertained any kind of conscious, pre-meditated thoughts along these lines, but do also grant me the poetic justice of our reacting to it thusly. And if that doesn’t work for you, imagine the absurdity of hearing of “Tomorrow Never Knows” anywhere else in the track order; try, especially listening to it as either the first or last track on side A and then listening to any other track afterwards. Or better yet, relax and enjoy it in place, just the way it is.
Man, I sure do get off on studies of cultural shifts.